Newspaper and Online News
2022 Abstracts
Research Paper • Student • Open Competition • Deceptive Power of Fake News: Perception of Believability Centers around Visuals, News Media, Social Media and Shared Values • Mohammad Ali, Syracuse University; Dennis Kinsey, Syracuse University • This paper examined a sample of 32 different types of fake news items to understand people’s perceptions of deception in various types of fake news items, regardless of communicators’ intend to deceive. Using Q Methodology, this study yielded five types of fake news content (e.g., visuals, social media, congruence, news media, and unknown sources) that different groups of people perceive as (un)likely to be deceptive. Findings should help better understand and combat fake news.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • Rethinking hybridity in diaspora journalism: A study of exiled Syrian journalists’ advocacy networks and role perceptions • Rana Arafat, City University of London • Using digital ethnography and in-depth interviews, this study offers a comprehensive understanding of how diaspora journalists maintain connections with their authoritarian homeland and advocate for transnational human rights and political reforms after fleeing its repressive political sphere. To this end, the paper examines how anti-regime Syrian diaspora journalists engage in transnational advocacy practices through building hybrid digital networks that blur boundaries between journalism, activism, human rights advocacy, social movements, and civil society work. The paper further investigates how these advocacy practices shape the diaspora journalists’ perceptions of their roles as well as their understanding of the different political, economic, procedural, organizational, and professional factors that influence how they perform them. Findings demonstrate that diaspora advocacy journalism poses various challenges to traditional journalism paradigms as journalists’ roles go beyond news gathering and publishing to include petitioning, creating transnational solidarity, collaborating with civil society organizations, and carrying out various institutional work. Sensational coverage, state intervention, journalists’ political leanings, funding pressure, and accessibility of sources also pose serious limitations to diaspora journalists’ advocacy efforts. An advanced theoretical model that maps out the influencing factors on news reporting and advocacy networking in the unique transnational conflict context is further proposed.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • Elite Journalists’ Narrative Evolution in the 2018 Midterm Elections on Twitter and in Print • Mitchell Bard, Iona College; Michael Mirer, University of Wisconsin – Milwaukee • A qualitative textual analysis of tweets and articles by elite newspaper journalists on and after election night in 2018 relating to the shifting narratives relative to whether or not the Democrats enjoyed a “blue wave” victory in the midterm elections. Results show that frames set on Twitter on election night persisted for five days in the New York Times, Washington Post, and Wall Street Journal before a new narrative took hold.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • The Impact of Public Transparency Infrastructure on Data Journalism: A Comparative Analysis between Information-rich and Information-poor Countries • Jason Martin, DePaul University; Gerry Lanosga, Indiana University • This study surveyed data journalists from 71 countries (N=345) and analyzed 483 data journalism projects from 50 countries to compare how transparency initiatives influence data journalism process and product. Differences in data journalists’ attitudes toward data from public institutions, types of data used, and topics covered in data-driven projects were examined. We find cross-national differences are explained by contextual factors related to transparency infrastructure, which influences the potential of data journalism to hold government accountable.
Extended Abstract • Faculty • Open Competition • The Best of Times, the Worst of Times: The Impact of Covid-19 on Digital Subscriptions • Hsiang Iris Chyi, University of Texas at Austin • A persistent problem facing U.S. newspapers is users’ lukewarm response to their digital offerings. The print edition, despite continued disinvestment and dramatic price hikes, remained the most consumed format for most newspapers. Has COVID-19 changed this and narrowed the persistent print-digital gap? Among the 20 newspapers under study, most reported substantial growth in digital subscriptions. However, the quickened declines in print circulation and the gigantic print-digital price gap have caused a decline in overall revenue.
Extended Abstract • Faculty • Open Competition • Promises granted: Venture philanthropy and the tech industry’s increasing authority over the journalism field • Brian Creech, Temple University; Perry Parks, Michigan State University • The past half-decade has seen the rise of venture philanthropy as specific kind of charitable giving in the journalism industry driven by actors in tech industry, primarily Google and Facebook. This paper interrogates venture philanthropy as a specific kind of shift in the journalistic field, discursively intervening in order to define sustainability and market success as partially dependent on actors and structures from the tech industry.
Extended Abstract • Faculty • Open Competition • Diversity Sourcing Tool: Intentions, Self-Observation and Learning • Lucinda Davenport, Michigan State University; Joseph Grimm, Michigan State University • By intentionally engaging the diverse groups that comprise a community, journalists build trust that all people are being represented and informed. This research used mixed methods to learn if a new sourcing tool helps students in real-time to intentionally include diverse sources in their coverage. Preliminary results appear to indicate that the sourcing tool is successful, which could have implications for building trust with audiences and helping journalists analyze sources real time instead of after-the-fact.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • Reciprocal Journalism’s Double-Edged Sword: How Journalists Resolve Cognitive Dissonance after Experiencing Harassment from Audiences on Social Media • Danielle Deavours, University of Montevallo; Will Heath; Kaitlin Miller, University of Alabama; Misha Viehouser; Sandra Palacios Plugge; Ryan Broussard • Reciprocal journalism is a daily practice for most American journalists. Previous studies have shown this practice benefits journalists, their newsrooms, and the audience (e.g. Coddington, Lewis & Holton, 2018; Barnidge et al., 2020). Although scholars like Lewis, Zamith, and Coddington (2020) provide evidence that journalists experience harassment when interacting with audiences online, causing them to view audiences less favorably, further explanation is needed as to why journalists would continue to practice reciprocal journalism if it subjects them to online abuse. Through in-depth interviews with professional journalists, the study finds journalists experience cognitive dissonance after experiencing harassment during reciprocal journalism, but they are not likely to stop practicing interacting with audiences due primarily to organizational and individual benefits that are perceived as greater than the negatives in audience interactions. Additionally, the study finds journalists feel personally responsible for resolving feelings of dissonance and often use unhealthy dissonance resolution techniques like avoidance, victim blaming, or perspective-taking to deal with online abuse. The end result could mean dangerous consequences for individuals and the industry long-term. Results suggest a cultural shift in the industry would be necessary to significantly ease dissonant cognitions among individual journalists. Through the examination of harassment’s effect on journalists’ willingness to interact with audiences on social media, this study expands current understandings of the normative practice of reciprocal journalism.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • Struggling to stay alive: Russia’s provincial journalism adapts to the COVID-19 pandemic • Elina Erzikova, Central Michigan University; Wilson Lowrey • This study adopts an ecological approach in examining Russian regional journalists’ adaptations to COVID-19. Interviews with journalists showed that a worsened economic situation has led to increased dependence on government subsidies. Generally, journalists avoided questioning authorities’ response to COVID, with some publishing government press releases and others focusing on practical tips for readers. There was also some minor deviance via social media. Overall, the crisis aggravated ongoing problems that have already been crippling these newspapers.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • “I Didn’t Know How We Were Going to Survive”: COVID-19’s Disruption of U.S. Community Newspapers • Teri Finneman, University of Kansas; Will Mari, Louisiana State University; Ryan Thomas • As journalists dealt with a nonstop news cycle in the early months of the pandemic, many of their newspapers also faced financial distress. Unable to rely on their centuries-old, ad-centric business model, U.S. community newspapers had to turn to other resources to survive. This study features oral histories with 24 journalists and state newspaper association directors in six states for a deeper understanding of how community newspapers survived the industry’s economic crisis in early 2020.
Research Paper • Professional • Open Competition • Elephant in the room: A study of the impact of emotional experiences on burnout among Chinese reporters • Lei Guo • Drawing on Grandey’s model of emotional regulation at work, this study is conceived to examine emotional experience of Chinese frontline reporters and its effects on their job burnout. The survey with 276 Chinese reporters reveals the effect of the demand on emotions at work and reporters’ experience of engaging in emotional labor magnify their levels of job burnout. Meanwhile, the use of problem-focused coping strategies can help reporters reduce their job burnout caused by emotional labor engagement. Findings in this study fill the gap in understanding the mechanism of reporters’ emotional labor engagement and its impacts on their job burnout. The theoretical and empirical implications of these findings are discussed.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • How partisan is partisan? Media framing of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Job Act • Amanda Comfort; Beverly Horvit, University of Missouri; Camille McManus • In 2017, Congress passed huge changes to the tax code. A mixed methods framing analysis of Fox News and CNN online news and Associated Press coverage shows they reported the same issues – the wealthy and corporations would benefit, and deficits would rise. All three relied most on Republican sources, but Fox News turned more frequently to conservatives than did CNN, and CNN cited more liberal sources than Fox. AP coverage fell between the two.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • Predicting News Sharing in Social Media from an Integrated Approach • Su Jung Kim, University of Southern California; Jacob Nelson, Arizona State University • News sharing on social media has become one of the central components of news production, consumption, and (re)distribution. Yet studies of social media platforms as a news channel have suffered from three significant limitations: a failure to consider the interplay between situational and individual factors, a dependence on U.S.-based data, and a lack of distinction between types of sharing behavior. The result is a portrait of social media news sharing that exaggerates the role of news content and downplays the characteristics of social media platforms as well as people’s own preferences and perceptions when it comes to news and social media more generally. This study addresses these gaps by drawing on survey data collected from a representative sample (N=1,008) of the South Korean population by Nielsen Company Korea (Nielsen, hereafter) to examine how individual and situational factors within the social media environment influence different types of social media news. Our results offer a clearer portrait of how and why people share news via social media, one where the individual characteristics of both news stories and news audiences are just one piece of the puzzle that determines news sharing.
Extended Abstract • Faculty • Open Competition • A Reckoning for the Media Industry: Examining the implementation of CSR communication on diversity • Allie Kosterich, Fordham University Gabelli School of Business; Ziek Paul • In this paper, we aim to understand if and how corporate social responsibility communication related to diversity from news organizations deemed to have more successful diversity practices differs from that of those with less successful diversity practices. Understanding the relationship between successful, institutionalized diversity practices and CSR communication is important, especially as news organizations attempt to integrate and institutionalize their diversity commitments within the context of other CSR priorities and the news media landscape at large.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • Media and Good Governance: Examining Role of Valenced Framing in Perceptions of Good Governance • Juan Liu, Columbus State University • Media play a vital role in strengthening and promoting good governance. This study explores how valenced frames affect perceptions of good governance by examining two governance issues (Flint water crisis and Syrian refugee crisis). The study reveals that participants exposed to good governance framing of issues yield higher approval of government performance than participants exposed to bad governance news stories. An analysis of moderating influence of political knowledge reveals that participants with higher levels of political knowledge are more susceptible to valence framing effect, but this pattern is only found in the case of Syrian refugees. These findings contribute to a growing body of research and literature around valence framing effect. The study then addresses these results in the context of on-going critical governance issues.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • Getting News from Social Media Influencers and from Legacy News Media in Seven Countries: The ‘More-and-more’ Phenomenon and the New Opinion Leadership • Justin Martin; Krishna Sharma • This study examined media use and media-related attitudes as predictors of getting news from social media influencers (SMIs) in seven Arab countries (N=5,166). The study hypothesized that getting news from SMIs is not an “alternative” for people who are disenchanted with mainstream news, but rather that SMI news use is, itself, a form of mainstream news consumption. Specifically, we hypothesized that getting news from legacy digital media and even from print media would positively predict SMI news use. This hypothesis was largely supported. In all seven countries, digital legacy news use was a strong, positive predictor of actively acquiring news from SMIs, providing strong evidence of the more-and-more phenomenon first identified by Lazarsfeld et al. (1944). Moreover, in none of the countries was a belief in media credibility negatively associated with acquiring news from SMIs, a relationship we would expect to see if SMIs represented a mainstream news alternative. Implications for research on SMIs, digital news acquisition, and media credibility are discussed.
Extended Abstract • Faculty • Open Competition • Evaluating the effects of solutions and constructive journalism: A systematic review of audience-focused research • Karen McIntyre, Virginia Commonwealth University; Kyser Lough • The practice and study of constructive and solutions journalism has been growing in recent years, led by claims of positive audience effects. However, the results sometimes conflict with one another. At this stage, we find it necessary to systematically review the existing literature on the effects of solutions and constructive journalism in order to 1) better understand the bigger picture of potential effects and 2) provide guidance for future research.
Extended Abstract • Faculty • Open Competition • The Role of Self-Categorization and Perceptual Media Effects in Selective Exposure to Election Fact-Checking • Dylan McLemore, University of Central Arkansas; Christopher Roland, University of Central Arkansas • As newsrooms devote more resources to fact-checking, this study considers the social psychological factors that influence whether people will actually read them, and if they do, what perceptions they’ll take away. Third-person perception and hostile media perception predicted avoidance of fact-checking election content. The degree to which a supporter self-categorized with a candidate, however, did not significantly affect selective exposure to or perceptions of fact-checking. A summary of the study is presented within the confines of a 1,500-word extended abstract.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • The numbers game: How local newspapers used statistics to frame the coronavirus pandemic • Newly Paul, University of North Texas; Gwendelyn Nisbett, University of North Texas • Data and visualizations are an important part of local health news. Systematic data sourced from credible sources provide context to stories and educate audiences. Data visualizations help simplify complex statistical information and increase audience interactivity. Journalists associate statistics with objectivity, and use them to quantify risk in crisis situations. This study explores how local news used data to cover the coronavirus pandemic. We examined 170 data-driven articles published in the Dallas Morning News and the Houston Chronicle to examine the predominant data sources, data-driven narratives, and use of interactive elements. Results indicate reliance on government sources, prevalence of hard news stories, localization of statistics, contextual presentation of data, and abundant use of visualizations. However, the coverage lacked human-interest stories, interactivity in infographics, and failed to adequately reflect the diversity of the communities covered by the two newspapers. Data-driven stories did not always provide access to the underlying databases; nor did they always explain the methodology used to gather and analyze the data. While the readable format of the articles and the updates on infection rates can inform audiences, we argue that coverage that ignores broader data trends can cause readers to feel negative, which can push them toward news avoidance.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • How Journalists Think About the First Amendment Vis-à-Vis Their Coverage of Hate Groups • Gregory Perreault; Jon Peters; Brett Johnson; Leslie Klein • This study, based on in-depth interviews with U.S.-based journalists (n=18), explores the increasingly fraught circumstances in journalistic reporting on white supremacists. We examine how journalists think about the First Amendment vis-à-vis their coverage of hate groups. Through the lens of media ecology, and First Amendment principles and theories, we argue ultimately that journalists who cover hate groups use the First Amendment to identify their place in the journalistic environment.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • #BREAKING in L.A.: Twitter Use in a Regional News Market • Frank Russell, California State University Fullerton; Miguel Hernandez; Korryn Sanchez • This quantitative content analysis, based on gatekeeping theory, examines Twitter use by Los Angeles news media. Network broadcasters, nonprofit news media, and the Los Angeles Times demonstrated skillful use of Twitter affordances: quote tweets, retweets, hashtags, mentions, and video. However, commercial broadcasters used these functions mainly for branding. Broadcasters were more likely to post or share tweets about weather, crime, and traffic, while two resource-constrained newspapers were more likely to post about sports.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • Seeing Red: Reading Uncivil News Comments Guided by Personality Characteristics • Arthur Santana; Toby Hopp • Whether on a news or a social networking site, comments following news stories are often beset with incivility. This article uses a Uses & Gratifications framework to understand why certain people are more drawn to uncivil comments than civil ones. Using eye-tracking technology, this research compares the attention a reader gives to uncivil comments and compares it against certain personality characteristics. Findings suggest that certain readers spend more time reading uncivil comments than civil ones.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • Who, What, and How: Analyzing Judicial Constructions of Journalism in Twenty-First Century Cases • Jared Schroeder, Southern Methodist University • Emerging technologies have increasingly challenged the role of journalism in the information ecosystem, leaving journalists and journalism scholars to reexamine the role and mission of journalism in democratic society. At the same time, state and federal judges have constructed a discourse regarding how they define journalism in the twenty-first century. They have done so while facing a variety of cases in which bloggers, message board posters, website publishers, and others have claimed protections that have historically been primarily associated with traditional journalists. Ultimately, judges have constructed a discourse about journalism that combined concerns regarding how closely the process and practices the publishers used to gather and communicate the information aligned with traditional journalistic work, the public-service value of the information, and the journalistic credentials of the publisher. Though concern for how the work was created and who communicated it, jurists consistently conveyed the public-service role was most instrumental in their evaluations, often rationalizing broad expansions of what legally constitutes journalism.
Research Paper • Student • Open Competition • Intermedia Agenda Setting during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Computational Analysis of China’s Online News • Hanxiao Wang; Jian Shi, Syracuse University • Based on intermedia agenda setting, the current study examines how official media and semi-privatized commercial media on Weibo platform covered the COVID-19 pandemic. Both supervised machine learning and time series analysis were employed to analyze 350,059 Weibo posts released by 3,883 news sources between December 2019 and April 2020. Our results indicated that China’s official media did not necessarily set the agenda for semi-privatized commercial media in this highly controlled media environment. Implications were discussed.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • Flooding the Gates: Conservative Media, Hunter Biden’s Laptop Conspiracy and Gatekeeping in the Social Media Era • Burton Speakman, Kennesaw State University; Aaron Atkins; Marcus Funk • Social media have eroded gatekeeping abilities of traditional, mainstream journalists and publications, allowing coordinated campaigns to force popular social media topics into mainstream news coverage. Analysis of a coordinated conservative campaign to promote a baseless conspiracy about Hunter Biden’s laptop in the waning weeks of the 2020 general election indicates that far right actors can overwhelm gatekeeping functions at conservative media by flooding social media with constant conversation on a favored topic. Similar efforts to flood mainstream news media with the same topic were partially successful but failed to overwhelm or manipulate mainstream gatekeeping. Findings suggest a new concept of “gateflooding” to describe manipulative and repetitive social media activity.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • An Evolutionary Approach to Why People Seek and Avoid More Information About Negative News Stories • ESTHER THORSON, Michigan State University; Carin Tunney, Michigan State University; Kevin Kryston, Michigan State University • Americans are awash in negative news. This study examines how people respond to reading negative stories. The amount of fear induced, story importance, efficacy feelings, and individuals’ attributes of optimism and perceived utility of news are all significant predictors of the degree to which people report intending to seek and avoid more information about the stories. The evolutionary psychology of human approach and avoidance is the guide to the design and interpretation of the study.
Research Paper • Professional • Open Competition • Redemption vs. #MeToo: How Journalists Addressed Kobe Bryant’s Rape Case in Crafting His Memory • Patrick Walters, Kutztown University • This study examines how journalists addressed Kobe Bryant’s 2003 rape case in coverage of his death. The qualitative textual analysis examines 488 stories, produced by 18 news organizations across the U.S. between Jan. 26 and Oct. 31, 2020. It finds most omitted the case, and that stories referencing it often included a sanitized version as part of a redemption narrative, a speed bump on Bryant’s road to greatness.
Research Paper • Faculty • Open Competition • Auditing whiteness: Structural barriers to antiracist newsrooms • Andrea Wenzel, Temple University • Newsrooms across the U.S. are struggling to address the effect of structural racism on stories they tell and who gets to tell them. This study explores the efforts of one news organization to pursue greater equity and inclusion. Using a combination of participant observation and interviews, it follows a metro newspaper through the process of conducting a diversity and inclusion audit of its content and newsroom practices. Drawing on Gidden’s structuration theory, it examines how whiteness is supported by layered and invisible structures including journalism norms, traditions, and practices that overrepresent white sources and center white audiences, structural racism that limits workplace opportunities, and limited local journalism funding. It then explores how journalistic agents either reproduce these norms and traditions or seek to transform the institution and its practices. Finally, taking a normative stance that more inclusive and antiracist journalistic practices are a goal that can and should be pursued, the paper reflects on how transformation may be aided by efforts that attempt to make visible and challenge structures of whiteness.
Extended Abstract • Faculty • Open Competition • Passive News Consumption, Social Media Use, and Public Perceptions of Journalistic Roles • Lars Willnat, Syracuse University; Yu Tian, Syracuse University • This study explores the relationship between passive news consumption (“News Finds Me”) and public support for traditional journalistic roles. Based on data from an online survey conducted in March 2021 with a national sample of 1,200 U.S. adults, we investigate how the individual components of the “News Finds Me” concept are associated with perceptions of journalists, trust in media, and four traditional journalistic roles (interpreter, disseminator, adversarial, and populist-mobilizer).
Research Paper • Student • Open Competition • Discerning Whether It’s ‘Fake’ News: The Relationship Between Social Media Use, Political Knowledge, Epistemic Political Efficacy, and Fake News Literacy • Avery Holton, University of Utah; Homero Gil de Zúñiga, University of Salamanca/Penn State University • This study contributes to unpacking mechanisms that help people identify fake news, seeking to theoretically connect people’s general social media use, political knowledge, and political epistemic efficacy with individuals’ fake news literacy. Results from a two-wave panel US survey data suggested that the more people used social media, were politically knowledgeable, and were able to find the truth in politics (epistemic political efficacy), the better the chances they could discern whether the news is ‘fake.’
Research Paper • Student • Open Competition • What You See and What You Think: Exploring News-ness Perceptions and News Media Repertoires in Singapore • Jingwei Zheng, Wee Kim Wee School of Communication and Information, Nanyang Technological University; Edson Tandoc Jr • This research explored how audiences in Singapore define news (i.e., news-ness) and how such understanding is shaped by the ways they access news (i.e., news media repertoires). Through a national survey, this study found five types of news repertoires as well as five types of news-ness perceptions. We also found that news-ness perceptions are related to how users access news. For example, news-ness perceptions of news omnivores differ from those of other types of users.
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • A profession in flux: How Covid-19 coverage is pushing the boundaries of traditional journalism • Kathleen Alaimo • This study argues that Covid-19 is a “critical incident” leading journalists to reconsider how and why they conduct newswork. A textual analysis of metajournalistic discourse in webinars and newspaper op-eds examines how journalists are evaluating news practice in response to Covid-19. Findings indicate that to protect standards of accuracy journalistic role conceptions, norms, and practices are in a state of renegotiation as journalists push the boundaries of “normal” journalism toward an emerging “post-normal” journalism.
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • It’s all rhetoric: Dominant climate change discourses in a UK and US newspaper • Kathleen Alaimo • This study argues that media discourse is influential in the formation of national climate legislation. Using the dominant climate discourses identified by Leichenko and O’Brien (2019), critical discourse analysis was employed to investigate the language of The Guardian and the New York Times. Findings indicate that UK elite press coverage is more integrative and critical than US reportage. Regarding the UK’s policy success US media might consider incorporating integrative and critical discourse in climate coverage.
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • How Newspapers’ Social Media Editors in Bangladesh Use Official Social Media Accounts • Ahmed Shatil Alam, University of Oklahoma; Wahida Alam, New Age • For the last several years, the newspaper industry in Bangladesh has been using social media for disseminating news and connecting with readers. This exploratory study sheds light on both issues through the lens of the Gatekeeping theory. Following interviews with 17 social media editors who worked for 14 national newspapers in Bangladesh, the study found that the overall traditional gatekeeping roles of these journalists had undergone substantial changes as they were heavily concerned about audience demands and reactions. Social media editors also feel pressured from their bosses, advertisers, and the audience to maintain their gatekeeping roles. These journalists even considered their jobs as “marketing” or “selling” of news and experienced volatile treatments from their colleagues in the newsrooms. Although they are in charge of multiple most of them had no prior training of any sort in social media management.
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • Journalists as Platypuses? — Understanding the Hysteresis and Habitus of media startups • Matthew Chew, Nanyang Technological University • “Media startups tend to stretch the boundaries of journalism, but are still influenced by values and ideas from legacy journalists. Guided by Bourdieu’s field theory, this study will utilize in-depth interviews to examine the disconnect between these new entrants and legacy newsrooms. This study proposes that there is a hysteresis in the field, which set the stage for media startups to flourish. These new agents don a media startup habitus, a blend of the traditional journalistic habitus and the startup habitus that is developed out of circumstance and as a response to the changing requirements of media and journalistic work.
Keywords: Field Theory, Startups, Habitus, Hysteresis, Journalistic Identity, Qualitative, Innovation, Mismatch”
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • For People, For Policy: Journalists’ Perceptions of Peace Journalism • Meagan Doll, University of Washington • Compared to studies on peace-journalism content, little research examines journalists’ perceptions of peace journalism despite theoretical suggestions that individuals influence content production. To address this relative disparity, this study examines the social conditions shaping journalists’ perceptions of peace journalism using a hierarchy-of-influences perspective and data from 20 interviews with East African journalists. Findings suggest that journalists understand peace journalism as either more people-oriented or policy-oriented and these perceptions correspond to varying degrees of professional precarity.
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • The Public’s Frame: News outlets, YouTube comments and the 2018 Teacher Strike in West Virginia • Laura Harbert, Ohio University • This paper summarizes a study of comments (N=1,961) posted on YouTube videos about the 2018 teacher strike in West Virginia. Analytics software and a hand-coded qualitative analysis of the text showed that themes of teachers, education, and people were prevalent, along with the nature of work in education, and fairness in teacher pay. Interdisciplinary and inter-methodological approaches in social analytics were discussed as a way to deepen understanding of media and journalism texts.
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • Post-Ghosting: The depletion of local government coverage after a county’s newspapers became ‘ghosts’ • Andrea Lorenz Nenque, University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill • This case study documents the decline over time of news about a rural county’s local government entities through quantitative and qualitative content analysis as the community lost its newspapers, finding that despite multiple online startups that sought to fill the gap, local government coverage suffered significant declines in both the quantity and quality of news stories once the newspapers disappeared. The community’s critical information need for local government news was left unfilled in the years following the closures.
Extended Abstract • Student • Student Papers • Extended Abstract: The State of Online News Advertising • Margaret McAlexander, University of Memphis • This research explores the prevalence of display and native advertising in online print news media. To achieve this goal, this research uses a content analysis of three newspapers ranking highly in circulation among major U.S. outlets over a full calendar year. This research provides an analysis of the state of online news advertising in 2020 through the collection of data regarding the presence or absence of advertisements and the qualities of such advertisements.
Extended Abstract • Student • Student Papers • Busking the News: Metajournalistic Discourse and Author-Audience Relationships on Substack • Rowan McMullen Cheng, University of Minnesota: Twin Cities – Hubbard School of Journalism and Mass Communication • This study examines author-audience relationships through Substack newsletters. Using the metajournalistic discourse framework, newsletter discourse is analyzed around two primary trends: (1) author-audience relationship maintenance, (2) boundaries between legacy media and newsletter authors. A qualitative textual analysis of 57 texts across 25 newsletters identifies that authors construct boundaries between themselves and legacy media as well as encourage audience participation. This study furthers research on journalistic labor, news audiences, metajournalistic discourse, and emerging digital formats.
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • An “assumption of bad faith”: Using fake news rhetoric to create journalistic teaching moments • Kelsey Mesmer, Wayne State University • Using the Communication Theory of Resilience, this project explores how journalists negotiate, adapt, and work to transform a social climate of hostility toward news media. Interviews with 38 journalists who frequently encounter anti-media rhetoric revealed strategies for mitigating this rhetoric, most commonly by turning conversations into teaching moments. By doing this, journalists educate the public about the purpose of the press and journalists’ routines, illuminating a critical, overlooked aspect of media and news literacy interventions.
Extended Abstract • Student • Student Papers • “Without a fixer, it is just an idea, but with a fixer, it will be a story.”: Bangladeshi local news producers’ perspectives on their work and extant challenges • Sohana Nasrin, University of Maryland; Bobbie Foster, University of Maryland Phillip Merrill College of Journalism; Md Mahfuzul Haque • Local news producers (referred to as LNP hereafter), sometimes known as “news fixers” or “fixers,” are an integral part of foreign news production. These local media workers serve as the eyes and ears of foreign correspondents in an unknown land and ensure the safety of foreign correspondents, especially in conflict zones. But perhaps the most important contribution of their labor is rendered through their interpretation of the events and occurrences so that the rest of the world can make sense of it all through the lens of journalistic storytelling. In this study, we present Bangladeshi local news producers’ case to understand their perspectives on their job. Through semi-structured in-depth interviews, we try to understand who they are and what impact they seek to have on the global journalism industry through their work. All of our interview participants identified cultural differences as a challenge. Our most important finding perhaps is that the local news producers still operate within a colonial framework. By focusing on Bangladeshi local news producers, we inform the existing literature in three significant ways: 1)We introduce local news producers labor in a developing country (i.e., Bangladesh) that usually gets international media attention while grappling with frequent natural disasters, poverty, migration, and other social anomalies, 2) We add the non-western perspective by focusing on the Global South, and 3)We contribute to understanding of the local news producers’ perspectives on their job instead of focusing on the foreign correspondents’ views on the local producers’ jobs.
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • How different market oriented news organizations portrayed news coverage about the CARES Act? • Michelle Rossi • Drawing from the CARES Act’s news coverage, this study investigated how different funding models in news organizations modulated the debate on the most expansive stimulus bill in modern American history. Market theory, news sources, and journalistic role performance in news content were the frameworks applied to this qualitative study. Some of the findings consist of differences in the assessment of objectivity as a journalistic norm, and similarities as the indirect use of government-official sources.
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • The Role of Anonymity and Race in Online News Story Comment Sections • William Singleton, University of Alabama • This study expands upon previous research examining incivility and negativity of online comments. Guided by deindividuation theory and its connection to anonymity, this study explores whether online comment forums associated with crime stories involving Black suspects yield more racially charged language than comment forums associated with crime stories involving white perpetrators. A quantitative content analysis of the comment sections in Advance Local’s news websites examined racial comments about crime stories involving Black and White criminal perpetrators and suspects. Findings revealed a significant association between crime stories and racial comments based on the race of the suspect. In addition, the study’s prediction that comment sections connected to Black crime stories would feature multiple comments with racial language also was supported.
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • Public Perceptions and Attitudes towards the Application of Artificial Intelligence in Journalism: From a China-based Survey • Wencai Hu; Mengru Sun, Zhejiang University; WEI HUANG • “In the face of the pervasive influence of artificial intelligence (AI) on journalism and media, the current research probe deeply into the public perceptions and attitudes towards the application of AI in Chinese journalism. The current study aims to answer several highly concerning questions by academics, the AI industry, and the journalism industry. A large online survey was conducted to examine the public’s existing knowledge, emotions, concerns, preferences, and expectations of AI in the Chinese journalism industry. It was found that the public is in general familiar with the application of AI technology in the field of journalism and media, among which the most acquainted aspect was describing some news products that apply the AI. The public’s emotions towards the news broadcast by AI simulated anchors were mainly positive. Compared with the news content, the public believed that the form of news report benefits most from the application of AI. The public prefers the types differently in terms of different media content and news production processes.
Finally, the majority of the public believed that AI and traditional modes should be complementary to each other in future news production. Practical suggestions were proposed to the AI industry, journalism, government, and the public.”
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • “Timely, Accurately, Avoid Unnecessary Panic”: How Vietnamese Newspapers Framed the COVID-19 Pandemic during the Initial Stage • Huu Dat Tran, Kansas State University; PHAM PHUONG UYEN DIEP, Kansas State University • Via content analysis of COVID-related articles (N = 1127) published in three prominent Vietnamese newspapers between January 23 and March 6, 2020, this study investigates how Vietnamese newspapers framed COVID-19 when it was first recognised in Vietnam, as well as their attempts to shape the public’s perception and behaviours towards the pandemic. Two frames, namely health severity and attribution of responsibility, were found to be predominantly used by VnExpress, Thanh Nien, and Tuoi Tre, thus highlighting the media’s role in Vietnam in disseminating information and calling for collective participation in pandemic precautions. Other elements, including the messages’ tone and sources, were also examined. Findings were then compared to previous studies concerning COVID-19 framing to illustrate the different approaches the media of various countries adopted. It should be noted that during the period, newspapers in Vietnam had to follow governmental orders, which required the media to provide punctual, accurate information while also avoid causing unnecessary panic. The argument that Vietnamese newspapers were a bridge connecting the Vietnamese government and their citizens and that they contributed to Vietnam’s initial victory against COVID-19 was supported.
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • Source Diversity in Nonprofit News: A Comparative Analysis of The 19th* and The New York Times • Carolina Velloso • This paper compares source diversity in The 19th*, a woman-focused nonprofit newsroom, and The New York Times. It also asks whether reporter gender influences sourcing patterns. Through a quantitative content analysis of 236 articles and 857 sources, this study interrogates whether The 19th* – which has the centering and elevating of women’s issues as its core objective – carries out that mission through greater inclusion of women as sources, both expert and non-expert, in its articles.
Extended Abstract • Student • Student Papers • Local Newspapers During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Understanding Journalists and Communities in Los Angeles • Courtney Weider, California State University, Northridge • This study examines how local newspapers have adapted during the COVID-19 pandemic, including how routines of journalists have been impacted and how they are engaging their communities. In-depth interviews were conducted with 25 journalists throughout Los Angeles, focusing on those serving Black and Latino neighborhoods that have been disproportionately impacted by the pandemic. Findings will advise newspapers, educators, and funders on how to support the local newspaper ecosystem to ensure communities stay informed and engaged.
Research Paper • Student • Student Papers • “The Chinese Virus” and Conditional Partisan Framing? An analysis of the cross-platform partisan framing in American news coverage of China’s role in the COVID-19 pandemic • Yiyan Zhang; Briana Trifiro, Boston University • The COVID-19 pandemic – a global public health crisis – has given rise to US new coverage about China, where the first cases were identified. However, the framing strategies used among different news outlets remain understudied. By conducting a structural topic modeling (STM) analysis on both website news and tweets published by 27 major US news outlets regarding China’s role in the COVID-19 pandemic, this paper examines how framing varied across left and right media and whether the publishing platform moderates the partisan framing. The results show support for both cross-partisan and cross-platform differences. Right media tend to adopt more sensational and attitudinal frames compared to left media. The gap between the two partisans was in general wider on Twitter than on news websites. Implications on media effects studies and activism against hate crimes are discussed.
Print friendly
